Back
Last updated: May 10, 2025

Self-Discrepancy Theory and Mental Health Effects

Self-discrepancy theory, developed by Edward Higgins in the 1980s, delves into the differences between our actual self (who we are), our ideal self (who we want to be), and our ought self (who we think we should be). These discrepancies can significantly influence our mental health and emotional well-being.

Key Concepts of Self-Discrepancy Theory

  • Actual Self: This is your current state, including your traits, attributes, and behaviors.
  • Ideal Self: This represents your hopes and aspirations, the person you strive to become.
  • Ought Self: This is based on societal expectations and obligations, focusing on what you feel you should do or be.

Understanding these components can shed light on various mental health challenges.

Impact on Mental Health

Emotional Well-Being

Discrepancies between these selves can lead to emotional distress. Here’s how:

  • Emotional Discrepancy: If your actual self doesn’t match your ideal self, you might experience feelings of disappointment and sadness. For example, someone who dreams of being fit but struggles with weight can feel inadequate.
  • Guilt and Anxiety: If your actual self falls short of your ought self, it can result in guilt and anxiety. Think of a student who feels they should be getting better grades but isn’t; they may experience stress and worry.

Psychological Disorders

Self-discrepancy theory also relates to various psychological disorders:

  • Depression: A significant gap between the actual and ideal self can lead to depressive symptoms. Individuals may feel hopeless when comparing themselves to their ideal self.
  • social anxiety: When individuals feel they must meet certain social standards (ought self) but don’t, it can lead to social anxiety. For instance, someone might fear judgment for not fitting in.

Real-Life Examples

  • Career Aspirations: Consider a young professional who aspires to be a manager (ideal self) but is currently in an entry-level position (actual self). The ongoing gap may lead to frustration and anxiety about their career trajectory.
  • Body Image: An individual may perceive their body (actual self) as not aligning with societal beauty standards (ought self), leading to body dissatisfaction and potential eating disorders.

Steps to Address Self-Discrepancies

  1. Self-Reflection: Take time to reflect on your actual, ideal, and ought selves. Journaling can be a helpful tool.
  2. Set Realistic Goals: Instead of aiming for perfection, set achievable goals that align more closely with your actual self.
  3. Seek Support: Talking to a therapist can help you navigate feelings of discrepancy and develop coping strategies.
  4. Practice Self-Compassion: Be kinder to yourself. Understand that it’s okay to have gaps; everyone experiences them.

Conclusion

While this exploration of self-discrepancy theory has highlighted its impact on mental health, emotional well-being, and psychological disorders, it’s essential to approach these discrepancies with understanding and compassion. Seeking help when needed can lead to a healthier relationship with oneself.

Dr. Neeshu Rathore

Dr. Neeshu Rathore

Clinical Psychologist, Associate Professor, and PhD Guide. Mental Health Advocate and Founder of PsyWellPath.